Saturday, June 19, 2010

Parting is such sweet sorrow

Parting is such sweet sorrow – William Shakespeare.

If anything is inevitable in this life on earth, parting is. No matter who we are, where we come from, what we do, what we try to do, parting is inevitable. Before our lives here on earth are through, we would have entered and left the lives of countless people, and have many do that to us in return.

At this time of the year, people at college are leaving or have left after having finished their exams. For many, it is merely a momentary farewell, a kind of ‘pause’ button that looks forward to the coming of the next semester, to the raucous screams, hugs and handshakes that greet bewildered passer-bys as friends who haven’t seen each other in a month renew and re-affirm their friendship.

For some however, this farewell might well be the last time that they meet each other in this life. A younger, more idealistic me might have tried to make the parting less painful by assuring my friends and myself that we would meet again in the near future. After all, with modern technology being what it is, flights are getting cheaper each year and we have a much greater probability of meeting each other again than our grandparents had. And with the friends that really matter, we most probably would. And yet it cannot be denied that sometimes, life catches up with us as work and other responsibilities start to come more and more into our lives as we ‘grow up’. The trips that we planned and dreamt of as undergraduates start to become less and less of a reality as we find ourselves being less able to take time off work, or if we are able, find that we would rather spend the time with our families, especially for those of us who have already started families of our own. The truth is, if we don’t make the effort within the first few years to travel to meet these far-flung friends of ours, as time passes, the chance of us doing that exponentially decreases. And the friends who we had promised we would meet again and would never forget start to fade away into the deepest recesses of our minds.

But this reflection isn’t meant to be a dampener; it is meant to be a celebration. But a celebration of friendship need not be premised on a constant remembrance of the person nor the real possibility that we meet up again. There are many people who can walk into our lives, even just for a short moment, who we might never meet again, and might never think of again even, at least not consciously, who might nonetheless have the greatest of impacts on our lives. To part is indeed sorrowful, but as the Bard reminds us, it is a sorrow that can be sweet. Indeed, it is this very sweetness of parting that allows us to call it a celebration.

Yet why would parting ever be sweet? Leaving aside cases of ‘friends’ we are happy to leave behind, and focusing on the friends who really matter, sweetness hardly seems to be the description that comes into one’s mind when one chances upon a group of friends bidding farewell to someone they might never meet again. There will probably be smiles of course, but there will probably be tears. Hugs, kisses, notes, presents, everything that one can think of to show that person that he/she is truly special might and will probably be given that day. Smiles and well wishes, yes, but if one is honest to one’s own feelings and emotions, more tears than smiles will be present that day. After all, this is a person who has meant a lot to you, and to leave with the thought that you might never meet each other again is a dreadful thought. It is not a happy thought in and of itself. The starkest example of course is when people farewell a loved one who has passed away. Such scenes are typically characterised by tears and comforting hugs, especially when the one who has passed away has seemingly had his/her life cruelly snatched away and had not had the chance to fulfil his/her potential.

And yet there are times when wakes and funerals have been an extraordinarily joyous affair. I must admit that I have never had the benefit of experiencing something like that, but a friend of mine did, and he described the funeral he went to as a raucous, joyous affair, full of laughter, music and fellowship. And though we don’t normally have that where we come from, yet there are strains of that in the practice of the eulogy, where we remember fondly, and kindly, the person’s life. Tears are usually shed then, but if it had been a full life, a life that had accomplished, and more importantly, loved much, then these tears are not merely tears of sadness at the thought of never meeting that person ever again, but tears of joy at having been involved with this person’s growth, at having had the chance to be influenced by such a person, at simply being able to share a precious moment with the dearly departed. There is sadness, yes, but there is joy too. Indeed, the sadness can only really come about because the person who has brought so much joy to us is no more. Sadness is only possible if joy is present; without joy, there would be no sadness at the passing of the person.

And so, parting, as mentioned earlier, is in and of itself not something to be desired if the person in question is a dear friend, someone who had brought much joy into our lives. But as the above example showed, parting can indeed be a sorrow underlined by much sweetness because of the joy that that person had brought into our lives. Still, there are three more reasons why parting can be such sweet sorrow for those of us who believe in an all-loving God who holds us and loves us into being every moment of the day.

For starters, we can be joyful to farewell someone we love because we trust that we will meet that person again someday, if not in the near future, then in the eventual future, when all of us will be gathered up into the hands of He who is Creator, Saviour, Lover. It is imperative to note that happiness is not the same as joy. Happiness is the emotion that we feel when things are going our way, when we got a first class in the subject that we took, or when someone we love loves us back in return. Joy however is deeper than that. One can be joyful and yet not be happy. For example, a pair of parents who had placed much hope in their only son to be a successful person in society, to get married and bring them many grandchildren, might not be extremely happy to find that he wants to join a religious order and lead a celibate life. Yet if they trust in the goodness and providence of the Lord, they might nonetheless be joyful that their son had been called and that he had found the courage necessary to pursue that path which leads to his freedom. Another example can be given of the parent who hands over her child to the police for a crime that he had committed. There is no great happiness in such an undertaking, but there can be joy in the knowledge and hope that doing so can help turn that young person’s life around, that he might now have the chance to really find himself and make something of himself.

The difference then between happiness and joy is that happiness is ‘grounded’ on things of the present while joy is underlined by a current of hope. The parents who gave their only son away to the seminary were unhappy because they were dwelling on the present disappointment that the hopes they had for him would not be fulfilled. But they can find joy by looking towards the future, trusting that the Lord will provide for him and for them even though almost all evidence point to the contrary. The parent who handed over her only child to the police would be sad at the present, especially if the child proves especially recalcitrant and verbally abused her for being a bad mother who betrayed him, but she can take solace in the hope that the present experience can prove to be a healing and liberating for her child, that he might return to society in the future and be a true asset to it.

In the same way, if we concentrate on the present, there is no denying that we can and will often be sad that someone who means so much to us is leaving, especially if it’s someone we might never meet again. But we can live with the hope that one day, eventually, we will meet each other again, when all the worries and strife of this life is gone, when all we have to ‘worry’ about is about living in the loving goodness of the Lord. And that is something we can be joyful about.

The second reason why parting can be such sweet sorrow is that we can leave that person in the best hands ever, Jesus’ nail-scarred hands. If we didn’t believe in a God who loves us unconditionally and tenaciously, in a God who will never stop seeking us out even though we find ways and means to run away from Him at times, then there might be reason to find parting to be merely a sorrowful affair. Not only do we not have the hope that we will meet again someday, we are unable to hope that the person leaves us with the guidance of He who is the Good Shepherd. But because we are able to place our faith in Christ crucified, “to Jews a stumbling block and to Gentiles foolishness” (1 Corinthians 1:23), we are able to trust that death is not the final answer and that the God who so loved the world that He gave His only Son would not leave us nor our friends in the lurch. For as St. Paul observed, “we may be unfaithful, but He is always faithful” (2 Tim 2:13). So parting can be sweet sorrow because we can trust that the next chapter of our friend’s life is what God has dreamt for him/her and is what will lead to his/her freedom, peace and joy.

And lastly, and perhaps most importantly, parting is such sweet sorrow because we can give thanks for all the good that our friend has brought into our lives. For all the joy and laughter, the food and drink that we share, more importantly, the love that made the food and drink taste better, the love that sustains us and gives us life. Sometimes, this love could be strained; we could find ourselves engaged in bitter arguments. But if we allow love to triumph and pride to fade, we might find that it is precisely such friendships that have weathered the storms of life, of egos and personalities, that, when it comes to the time to part, are the hardest to let go of. And so even though there might be much pain and tears shed in that relationship, it is nonetheless one for which we can give thanks for, and one which, even in the midst of parting, can bring smiles to us as we remember the best moments, which are often not the spectacular, lavish ones, but the ones that are grounded in the simplicity of everyday life and a genuine love and regard for each other. And of course, such moments are usually reciprocal and spontaneous, just as the best jokes are those that we spontaneously share with our friends for a joke, no matter how well though through, is only as good as the people who receive it; if there is no one to receive it, then it is merely a waste.

So thank you, my friends who are leaving and who I might never might meet again for coming into my life and enriching it with the beauty of who you are. You have taught me how to be a student again, how to enjoy the simple joys of making hot drink or dessert calls, how to waste my time in the coffee lounge for ages on end chatting about useless and useful matters, and most importantly, how to love and to allow myself to be loved by you. Thank you for allowing me into your life and sharing it with you. Thank you for bearing with my philosophical musings, my not-so-philosophical musings, my –jarring– music, my ever-constant whining and my desperate attempts to look and remain young. You will be missed dearly and rest assured that even when old age catches up with me and conscious memories of our time together fade into the blur that is life, some part of you will always be with me. Remembrance, as Henri Nouwen pointed out, is not simply a matter of recalling memories in one’s mind; to remember someone is to make him/her once again a member of the community, a re-membering, as it were. So the seeds that you have sown in my life might not be harvested by you, but rest assured that I will do my best to nurture it so that others might harvest where they have not planted, and in so doing, pass on all that I have learnt from you even though I might one day forget who had planted which seed. May you do the same too with those that I have had the fortune of planting in your life. And because I have no better idea how to end this, allow me to leave you with that age-old blessing:

The Irish Blessing
May the road rise up to meet you.
May the wind always be at your back.
May the sun shine warm upon your face,
and rains fall soft upon your fields.
And until we meet again,
May God hold you in the palm of His hand.

Wednesday, June 9, 2010

The Quiet Solid Love of St. Joseph

This was something I wrote some time in anticipation of St. Joseph's Day
------------------------------------------------------------------------

March 19th is an important day in the Church’s calendar. It is one of the 2 days that we celebrate the figure of St. Joseph, Jesus’ foster father, the other day being May 1st. We know next to nothing about St. Joseph – all that the Gospels tell us is that he was from the line of David, that he was a carpenter, that he was a righteous man who didn’t want to get married to a pregnant woman but yet loved her enough to not want to submit her to public humiliation and scorn and hence wanted to divorce her privately, that he took Mary to Bethlehem during the census, and then to Egypt to stay away from Herod’s wild massacre for power. We see him also at the temple where Simeon prophesied that Jesus would be “destined for the fall and rise of many in Israel” (Luke 2:34), and then one final time when Jesus simply went about his Father’s business without telling his earthly parents. Yet through all these episodes, not a word is uttered from Joseph’s lips. All the words are spoken by the other characters in the story – Mary, the angel, the Magi, the shepherds, Simeon, Anna and Jesus. One could say that he was the quintessential ‘solid, silent man’ type. The perfect husband perhaps? ;)

Why all these thoughts on Joseph you might wonder? After all, he seems like a rather bland character. Sure, he was the father of our Lord, but that’s about it. We don’t hear much of him and even if we did, his story would most certainly be eclipsed by his wife and his son. Who can compare to the Messiah and his mother after all?

Yet a certain passage by the most unlikely of sources today struck me during prayer today. Jean-Paul Sartre, that most erstwhile of atheists and archetypal existentialist, once wrote a Christmas play, Barjona, when he was in a prison camp during WWII. And he wrote this of that silent, solid man who worked behind the scenes to ensure that Jesus and Mary were provided for while Jesus grew up in ‘the hidden years’ away from the public eye:

"And Joseph? I would not paint Joseph. I would show no more than a shadow at the back of the stable, and two shining eyes. For I do not know what to say about Joseph, and Joseph does not know what to say about himself. He adores, and is happy to adore, and he feels himself slightly out of it. I believe he suffers without admitting it. He suffers because he sees how much this woman whom he loves resembles God; how she is already at the side of God. For God has burst like a bomb into the intimacy of this family. Joseph and Mary are separated for ever by this explosion of light. And I imagine that all through his life Joseph will be learning to accept this." Sartre

It is a beautiful and stunning image of this man who we know so little of, and yet was so important in the life of our Lord. Just imagine what would have happened to Mary and Jesus if Joseph was unwilling to trust in his vision, to let go of societal conventions and expectations and take Mary in as his wife.

As it is, Joseph put aside his fears and his well-laid plans to marry Mary in a socially conventional manner. He trusted that God was on their side and listened always to the prompting of the angel in Matthew as to what to do (to marry Mary and to flee to Egypt after the birth of Jesus).

But more than being simply a shining example of what it means to trust totally in God’s providence, Joseph is also a great teacher of love. Just imagine in your mind’s eye that nativity scene as ‘painted’ by Sartre. Note how he is simply contented to stay in the background of things; his ‘shining eyes’ showing just how wonderfully happy he is at what has happened before him. Indeed, as Sartre points out, he probably felt a bit ‘left out’, a little separated from Mary and Jesus. After all, this is not bone of his bone nor flesh of his flesh. He is simply called to be the foster father. And in that sense, Sartre is right – there is some sense of suffering on Joseph’s part.

But this suffering is inevitable in any relationship, much less between a man and the mother of God. There will always be some part of our partner’s life that we cannot share. There are the trivial things like how we can never see an object from exactly the same perspective; it just isn’t humanly possible. And then there are the more important issues like how, even though 2 people might have been together for a long time and understand each other really well, there are times when even they do not see eye to eye on certain issues. True, there are such things as ‘soul mates’, but even soul mates do not agree on everything.

And so Joseph suffers. He suffers because there is this woman he loves so deeply who has grown so much in her relationship to God that she has literally become one with him, giving birth to him, becoming his mother. This is something that he can never share with the 2 of them. This is a special bond that is exclusive to them. He will, as it were, always be the onlooker.

But note how Sartre describes him nonetheless. His eyes are “shining”, “he adores, and is happy to adore”, and “he suffers without admitting it”. This is not a picture of a man who is unhappy at being outshone by his wife, or one who is unhappy that he cannot fully share in the joyful scene before him. He is contented being just a shadow, just being 2 shining eyes in the background. He doesn’t admit to the suffering not because he is a masochistic person nor is he a gung-ho, testosterone-fuelled young male who feels that he has to be this ‘macho’ guy. Rather, he doesn’t admit to the suffering because at a deeper level, this ‘pain of separation’ between him and Mary is overcome by his love for her. He doesn’t have to be the person that she is closest to because he understands that her love for God doesn’t mean that she loves him any less. Indeed, he knows deep down that she loves him through and through, that she returns to him the love that he has for her. So yes, he cannot share this epiphany with her, and thus there is the pain of separation, but because he loves her, he is happy that she is happy, that she has been chosen to be the mother of God. If she is happy, then he is happy simply being 2 shining eyes in the background, looking on lovingly and protectively over mother and child.

And perhaps that’s what we can learn from this great man who is ever so silent and stoic. In today’s world, we often equate love with romance, thinking that if our partner doesn’t buy us flowers, doesn’t spend hours on end talking to us on the phone, rejects an offer to watch a movie or have dinner etc, that he/she doesn’t love us. Yet love, as shown by St. Joseph, is so much more. It is about truly understanding where the person is coming from, where he/she is at, emotionally, mentally and physically, and about letting the person grow and develop at his/her own pace. It is not about an impulsive and almost fanatical desire to share everything with the other. Some of that is good, but love always recognises that fundamentally, the other person will always remain an Other to us because he/she is a human being with free will. And love then allows the other to make their own decisions, to give space for the other to be their own person, to recognise that at some level, he/she will be a stranger to us, not in a bad sense, but rather as a kind of mystery. This may sound ridiculous to romantics out there who are bred on a diet of Hollywood rom-coms (romantic comedies), but if one wants to know the person through and through and not have any kind of mystery at all, one is probably best served hooking up with a computer or a robot. The human being with a free will will always be a mystery, and that adds, not detracts, to the beauty of love.

So perhaps today we can think about the ones we love, or have loved, and think about whether we can be like St. Joseph. Are we contented being shining eyes in the background, being a mere shadow, so long as he/she is happy and the one taking centrestage? Are we willing to allow the other person to grow freely with or without us, or do we simply want to possess them? Are we willing to allow the other person to love us the way and extent to which they wish and can love us like St. Joseph did, or do we demand that they fulfill our criteria and requirements for them?

Happy St. Joseph’s day in advance to all of you. :)