I have been meaning to write something about “bruised reeds” ever since reading a reflection on it by Henri Nouwen. It has been a topic of discussion between a friend and I at college, and as if God Himself were pushing me to write about it, yesterday’s first reading was just about that – “A bruised reed he shall not break, and a smoldering wick he shall not quench” (Isaiah 42:3). Let me first begin with that reflection by Nouwen:
-------------------
Not Breaking the Bruised Reeds
Some of us tend to do away with things that are slightly damaged. Instead of repairing them we say: "Well, I don't have time to fix it, I might as well throw it in the garbage can and buy a new one." Often we also treat people this way. We say: "Well, he has a problem with drinking; well, she is quite depressed; well, they have mismanaged their business...we'd better not take the risk of working with them." When we dismiss people out of hand because of their apparent woundedness, we stunt their lives by ignoring their gifts, which are often buried in their wounds.
We all are bruised reeds, whether our bruises are visible or not. The compassionate life is the life in which we believe that strength is hidden in weakness and that true community is a fellowship of the weak.
-------------------
Nouwen’s focus here is on how we treat people when we view them to be weak or ‘damaged’ in some form or manner. This is an undoubtedly true observation. But I want to focus today on 2 other things: firstly, that this crushing of bruised reeds extends even to the way we deal with our relationships with our friends, family, and the people we like, and secondly, that this way of acting is rooted not in God’s love, but in fear.
Staying at an undergraduate college has been an interesting and life-giving experience. For one thing, it has allowed me to reclaim my university years; the whole flirtation with the priesthood, while life-giving in some ways, had also resulted in a ‘black hole’ of sorts where my social life was concerned. Of course, I was never much of a party animal to begin with (okay, there’s really no need to snigger here guys…) but those 80-90% of those 3 years were quite literally spent in a church. My waking hours would be spent in church, either praying, studying, hanging out or doing some church stuff. My social group comprised people from church. And while there’s nothing wrong with that per se, it did mean that university became a mere backdrop to attaining a degree. But I digress. What’s really interesting about staying in an undergraduate college overseas is community life. It’s really hard to keep all to yourself (possible but hard) when you have to go for meals with 270 other students, when they see you in the most ridiculous attire because you had just literally rolled out of bed and into the dining hall. What I enjoy the most has to be the heart to heart talks that we have from time to time. And of course, being the young people that we are (STOP sniggering I say…), we talk about the one thing that almost all young people talk about – relationships.
Now whatever I’m going to say can be applied to all kinds of relationships, but the main focus will be on non-platonic, i.e. romantic, relationships simply because it is the one where people’s emotions are most invested and/or are stretched to the limits.
So over the past few weeks, over a few chats with several people, I’ve realised that oftentimes, people are at a loss at what to do when they reach a certain stage in a relationship with the person that they like – the stage before the ‘confession’. “What should I do?” is the most often asked question. “What does he/she mean when he/she does that?” is the second most often asked question. “Why does he/she do that?”, “Why is he/she blowing hot and then cold?”, “Am I reading too much into it?” etc. are the other common questions that come up. And if this stage of uncertainty lasts for more than a week or two, there is then the tendency to simply ‘throw in the towel’ and give up. For there is nothing more depressing nor energy-sapping than to get one’s hopes up, and then have it crushed, and then get it up, and crushed, and up, and crushed. It takes a psychological toll on people and in that sense, it is hardly surprising that some just want to give up.
Yet this isn’t the way that God acts. Let us read again that phrase from Isaiah: “A bruised reed he shall not break, and a smoldering wick he shall not quench”. The uncertainty of the situation has undoubtedly caused us to feel like the whole relationship has become something like a bruised reed. But unlike how God chooses not to break that bruised reed, oftentimes we choose to break it, choosing to make the uncertain situation certain by the force of our actions. Sometimes, this comes in the form of us simply ‘giving up’, ‘throwing in the towel’, choosing the seeming certainty of ‘no, there’s nothing between us’, rather than simply dwelling in the uncertainty of the situation. The irony, and the problem, is that to us who are in the situation, the option of ‘no, there’s nothing between us’ seems far more likely than ‘maybe there is’, when actually the possibilities could be equal. By choosing to make the uncertain situation certain, sometimes, we prematurely close off possibilities that could have resulted in something truly beautiful.
I remember a friend told me once a long time back that he and his girlfriend were “on the break”. He had been with his girlfriend for 5 years and this is usually the time when people start to review their relationship, examining if there is a true possibility of marriage, for if not, it would be time to move on. So this couple was “on the break”. Now being “on the break” doesn’t necessarily mean anything more than just that. It doesn’t have to mean “break up”. It could just as easily have meant “hey, I realised that I couldn’t do without you and I really want to be with you so let’s get back together and be even stronger in our relationship”. But after a few weeks of this business of “on the break”, my friend decided to push for a “break up” instead. The problem though was that the girlfriend had not yet decided whether to break up or not, but since he had decided to do so, they broke up. About a year later, he came to me and said, “I just realised that we were merely ‘on the break’ and not ‘breaking up’.”
We choose to crush the bruised reeds of our relationships because we cannot deal with the uncertainty of the situation. Brought up in a generation where instant gratification has become the norm, waiting in uncertainty has become uncomfortable for us. This also explains why we act in the ‘opposite direction’ sometimes, choosing to make the situation certain not by ‘giving up’, but by doubling, tripling, or even quadrupling our efforts to ‘get the guy/girl’. We become too intense, thinking that by our very actions, we can make the person react the way that we want them to react, forgetting that they too, like us, are free-willing human beings. Sometimes it works, and it reinforces the myth within us that we need to be ‘go-getters’, we need to have that ‘drive’ to make things happen. But sometimes all we succeed in doing is to push the other person away.
And this is the way we deal with our friends too. I remember how my friends have complained to me before about the way I deal with them. “Jarrod,” they observed, “You are extremely nice to people you have just met, and yet not so nice to friends who have been with you for a long time. Why is that the case? Shouldn’t it be the other way round?” And that stumped me for a while. I had to go away to reflect on my actions and admit to the truth behind that observation. I neglect my old friends, choosing instead to focus on my newly formed friendships, being extremely nice to them, doing all sorts of things for them. This isn’t wrong per se, but there was a lack of balance, and this lack of balance had to be addressed. Why, I wondered to myself, was I behaving in such a manner? Why was I, even with friends, ‘blowing hot and cold’, as it were? Why was I intensely friendly for one moment, and then not for another? From what source was this behaviour springing from?
And then the answer came to me – fear. Fear was the motivating drive within me that caused me to be this overly intense person seeking for affirmation from the people around me. With my old friends, I was safe and secure in the knowledge that they accepted me. But not so with my new friends. And so I chose to ‘crush’ the ‘bruised reed’ of my newly formed friendships, being extremely nice with them, hoping to make them my true friends, making them accept me etc. through the sheer force of my actions. The end result? Many of these newly formed friendships flourished for a brief moment in time, but as time went by, and as the intensity inevitably fell away (for I thought that I had by now cemented the foundations of our friendship and that I did not need to do anything more), many of these friendships fell away as well. We’re still friends of course, but these friendships which had burned brightly for a time can’t even hold a candle to those old friendships which my friends and I had lovingly, and slowly, nurtured over time. These old friendships had deep roots; the new ones didn’t. The new ones flowered quickly, and died quickly. The old ones took their time, but the fruit that it bore was sweet and life-giving. The fruit of fear might taste sweet now, but it is the fruit of love that proved more enduring and life-giving in the end.
In this time of Holy Week, as we continue to reflect on the Passion of our Lord, perhaps we can reflect on our relationships with people, be it platonic or not, and with ourselves. Oftentimes, we choose to crush the bruised reed because we cannot bring ourselves to accept the ‘cup of suffering’ that is uncertainty, choosing instead to drink the bitter poison of certainty that we concoct through our actions. But just as Jesus allowed himself to be ‘handed over’ to the chief priests to be crucified, knowing and trusting that the Father will be with him through it all, and that the Father will bring him through it, we too are invited to pray with Jesus those words of surrender – “Father, into your hands I commend my spirit”. Jesus’ hope was not based on his ability to affect events through his actions; his hope was based on a loving relationship with the Father who would do everything for him. It did not mean that he was free from the agony of uncertainty, as evidenced in the Agony in the Garden, but the hope that the Father will bring him through this suffering gave him the strength to stand up, to be ‘handed over’, and to be crucified. It is a hope grounded in nothing more than the certainty of love, and not a wish grounded in the certainty of actions. For a hope is open-ended while a wish is a desire for something concrete.
“Father, if it is your will, let this cup of suffering pass me by, yet let not my will but yours be done.”
Wednesday, April 7, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment