Judas, who betrayed him, said, "Surely not I, Rabbi?" He replied, "You have said so." – Matt 14:25
We all know about the story of Judas’ betrayal. How he did it, and supposedly, for what he did it. The Gospel of Matthew tells us that he went up to the chief priests and asked them what they were willing to give him if he was going to hand Jesus over to them. 30 silver pieces was their answer, and for 30 silver pieces, our Lord was crucified. Or so the romantic/poetic picture that most of us have in our minds. It’s sad, but there’s a certain ‘ring’ to it, a certain literary flair – for 30 silver pieces was he betrayed; a life for 30 silver pieces; the King of kings, the Lord of lords, for 30 silver pieces; and on and on. But was it really that simple?
It’s hard to imagine anyone who had travelled with our Lord, been one of his closest confidants and aides, seen him work countless miracles, heard him preach about the Kingdom of God, experienced first hand the unconditional and healing love of the One who is Love, having a turn of heart. The Gospel of John does explicitly say the following: “After he took the morsel, Satan entered him.” (John 13:27). But let’s not forget that not too long ago, Jesus called Peter “Satan” as well – “At this he turned around and, looking at his disciples, rebuked Peter and said, "Get behind me, Satan. You are thinking not as God does, but as human beings do." (Mark 8:33) So placing too much emphasis on that part of the Gospel, as if Judas was really the evil one, might be a little hasty. Again, we must consider that this man had travelled with our Lord for the better part of 3 years. Can it be that not a single part of his soul was touched by the many experiences of love that he saw and witnessed? Can it be that no healing ever took place in that heart of his? I find that a bit hard to believe. So what gives? Why did Judas betray Jesus?
The thought of the day provided by Sacred Space (www.sacredspace.ie – a wonderful place for daily prayer) was this: I ask for compassion for all who, like Judas, have been brought to a point of denial.
If Judas was really betraying Jesus, and he knew that he was, why would he have said to our Lord, “Surely not I, Rabbi?” Perhaps he might, if he was a perverse person, testing, as it were, our Lord’s ability to foretell the future. If so, there is a sense of vindictiveness about Judas that might be coherent with the image of him rebuking Mary for spending 300 denarii on a jar of costly perfume with which she anointed our Lord’s feet (Monday’s Gospel reading). Perhaps. I don’t think we can ever know the reason for sure. A lot of what we are doing here is simply speculation. But speculation can nonetheless be instructive in some manner.
One of the traditions surrounding Judas was that he did not intend to betray our Lord. Rather, what he meant to do was to push Jesus to do something to bring about the Kingdom of God. In this tradition, Judas is presented not as a betrayer, but someone who was impatient for the coming about of the Kingdom of God. He did not understand, like all the disciples, that the Kingdom of God was not to be an earthly kingdom where Christ would rule and the Jews would be the glorious people once more. He was frustrated that Jesus was merely talking, merely healing, merely doing good works, and yet not in direct conflict with the authorities, not directly bringing about an earthy kingdom. So he tried to force Jesus’ hands by handing him over to the authorities. The advantage of such a story is that it provides us with a very good reason why he would go and commit suicide at the death of our Lord. After all, if his intention was to betray our Lord, why feel guilt, and to such an extent as to kill himself? It also helps us to make sense of that seeming disjunct that I pointed out earlier – that this was the same man who travelled with our Lord for the better part of 3 years and yet was not moved to be a better person.
Again, whether this is true or not is something that we probably will never be able to prove. But it is instructive nonetheless. For what it points out is that even when we do not outrightly deny or betray Jesus, if what we do is in direct opposition with what he has in mind, even if what we intend is good, then we are, in a very real sense, betraying him. This was why Jesus could say to Peter, the one he entrusted his church to, “Get thee behind me Satan”. For anyone who would prevent him from entering into his passion, from doing the will of his Father, is, for all purposes, Satan. The Gospel of Mark, Chapter 1, has 3 such examples. In that chapter, Jesus healed the man with the unclean spirit in the temple, he healed many people who were sick with various diseases, driving out many demons, and he healed the leper. In each particular case, Jesus expressly tells the unclean spirits/demon/leper not to reveal who he is to the world. “Quiet!” he said in reply to the unclean spirit’s exclamation that he was the Son of God. He didn’t “permit [the demons] to speak because they knew him”. And he told the leper, “See that you tell no one anything”. To us, this might sound a little mystifying. After all, shouldn’t he want the world to know that he was the Son of God? Wasn’t that what he came to do? So why keep it a secret? Indeed, Biblical scholars have termed this the “Messianic Secret”, the secret that Jesus was the Messiah. The question is “why”.
And the answer is pretty straightforward in the end, and also fits in with why Jesus simply didn’t just come off the cross during the crucifixion. For after all, if you were present at the crucifixion, would you not have believed that he was God if he had simply stepped down from the cross, show that he was not dead, that his wounds have healed etc? Such a spectacular representation of his Godhead would have garnered him many followers. But at what cost? Many would then have followed him not because of the message of unconditional love that he was preaching, but because of the works and miracles that he could do for them. This was why Jesus wanted to keep his divinity a secret. And yet the good-intentioned leper, for indeed he had good intentions, “spread the report abroad so that it was impossible for Jesus to enter a town openly” such that “he remained outside in deserted places” (Mark 1:45). This perhaps wasn’t how Jesus wanted to start his ministry, on the premise that he could work wonders for people. He wanted them to first hear his message, to believe his message for what it is, and not because he could work miracles for them. For, as St Teresa of Avila would put it, are we seeking the consolation of God or the God of consolation? There is a subtle but nonetheless significant gap between the two.
Which brings us back to Judas, Peter, and the point I had brought up earlier. That so long as our actions, even if good-intentioned, work in direct opposition with God’s will, then we are, in a very real sense, betraying him. If the tradition is right, then Judas’ fault was in trying to force the hand of Jesus, to make present the Kingdom of God in an earthly manner. Peter’s fault was in trying to prevent Jesus from suffering the passion. Both were at fault in trying to prevent the will of God from being accomplished. And both were, as it were, called Satan in the Gospels.
For me, these 2 ‘betrayers’ of our Lord teach us 2 important lessons. Firstly, the Kingdom of God is not an earthly kingdom, and it is not to be spread in an earthly manner. The Holy Crusades are one such example of an earthly endeavour by an earthly kingdom and one definite way not to spread God’s kingdom. Indeed, the current Islam-West conflict can be traced back to the time of the crusades. Secondly, and more importantly I feel, we must allow the will of God to be fulfilled in this world, even if it seems as though it will lead us, and the people around us, into our very own passion and crucifixion.
We don’t like to suffer. That seems like a brute fact, if anything is. All our lives, we try to find ways and means not to suffer. Even the people who cut themselves to ‘feel alive’ are doing it because they don’t want to suffer the thought of not being alive. We exchange bigger sufferings for smaller sufferings. And if possible, have a life without any suffering at all. This explains why ridiculous notions such as the Gospel of Prosperity can take root and be so popular around the world. For there is an innate desire in man to be happy and one of the ways to be happy is to have many things and not to have any suffering. But we preach a Crucified Christ or, as St. Paul said, “we preach Christ crucified, to Jews a stumbling block and to Gentiles foolishness” (1 Corinthians 1:23). A Resurrected Christ, yes, but one who was Crucified. New life can only come about if a Death has first taken place.
Indeed, while we should do everything we can to alleviate the suffering of many people around the world, there are sometimes, in my opinion, that people should be allowed to suffer. I’m not trying to be a sadist here or try to justify a conclusion that states that the people who are in dire poverty and hunger have only themselves to blame. I think that the work that many charity and missionary organisations are doing are very good. But at the same time, there is something to be said about allowing people to suffer. Too often in our society, we do not allow people to suffer. For example, we might say, with good intentions, to someone who had just lost a family member or friend that it’s okay, that they will always be in your heart etc. And that’s good. But sometimes we don’t allow them the time and space to grieve. Sometimes what they need to do isn’t to hear our platitudes about how there is life after death, about how he who passes on will forever be remembered etc. Sometimes, what they need to do is to simply grieve, to mourn, for something has died within them. For new life to take place, for them to truly come to terms with their loss, true grieving must take place. If we don’t allow them to grieve, we don’t allow them to embrace the loss, and we don’t allow them to turn that death into a new life without that person. In the short term, we may, with gifts, with jokes, with various entertainment devices, be able to distract them from their loss. Coping, as some people may call it. We may help them to cope in the short term. But in the long term, if the loss is truly a deep one, then the pain and hurt will return. All we have succeeded in doing is to paper over the cracks, and when the cracks reappear, the pain would be greater for the wound have festered in the meantime.
Another example would be allowing young people to make their own mistakes. I remember a colleague of mine who was expressing her frustration to me that her student had not come for remedial even though the A levels was very near and she had called him specially to do so. My reaction was why she was frustrated. At the end of the day, it is his exam and it is his life. As teachers, we are duty bound to help them and to point them in the right direction. But we are not to constantly give them a push in the right direction for that is ineffective. We only have to think about how ineffective an all-too paternalistic society can be in terms of building up the characters of its people. Behaviour can be modified through fear of punishment, but not character cannot be built in such manner. Coming back to the colleague, the question I had for her was this: who cannot fail? You or the student? Why can we not allow our students to fail? Is it really such a bad thing? Perhaps failing now might be the wake up call he needs to then embark on a totally new direction in life. Perhaps failure would be the catalyst to be the great person that he can be. But we have been taught so often, and so harshly, in Singapore that failure is not an option. And so we don’t allow others to fail. We don’t allow ourselves to fail.
Yesterday, we talked about the bruised reeds and the agony of waiting and of being vulnerable. We talked about how difficult it was to be waiting in uncertainty, not knowing what would happen, and how sometimes we choose the ‘easier’ path of making things certain through the sheer force of our actions, not unlike what Judas might have done. Not allowing ourselves to suffer is one such way. Not allowing ourselves to partake in our own passion, in our own way of the cross, and others too, is to be like Peter, to stand in the way of Jesus and to prevent him from taking up his cross and dying for us. There is a redemptive quality to suffering, and we must not run away from it. Sometimes, prudence tells us that we should sidestep it. In those cases, the light of human reason can guide us to do what is right. But other times, the light of the Holy Spirit guides us to embrace the suffering of our lives and to allow and help others to do the same. We might think it weird and masochistic even to think that suffering should be embraced in such a manner. But much good and growth can come out of that experience. If, for example, that Mary chose not to suffer the uncertainty of what would happen to her if she answered yes to the angel Gabriel (do not doubt for one second that it was the darkest moment in her life for she knew not what Joseph’s, her parents’, her neighbours’ reaction would be), we would not be here today talking about Easter even. If Jesus had simply prayed, “Father, if is your will, let this cup of suffering pass me by” and stopped there, there would be no Easter as well. If countless Christian martyrs had not said “yes” to Christ’s exhortation to spread and preach the Gospel to the ends of the world, we would not have known of this man who died a criminal two thousand years ago.
To shy away from the passion in our lives is, in a real sense, to be a Peter or a Judas.
And the last thought I will leave you with is this: Peter embraced the suffering of denying Jesus and became the first leader of the Church. Peter the denier became St. Peter. The true tragedy of Judas was not that he betrayed Jesus, but that he could have been St. Judas.
May we embrace the crosses in our lives today, and in the days to come.
"If, then, we have died with Christ, we believe that we shall also live with him." (Romans 6:8)
Wednesday, April 7, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment